Untenable
THE Iranian Myth of its "whiteness"
Considerations
Historical context, current perspectives, and international relations implications.
main contents
- Historical origins: Traces the Aryan myth from European Orientalism to Iranian nationalist appropriation.
- Legal classification: Examines the U.S. legal case that classified Iranians as white.
- Diaspora identity: Analyzes the racial paradox faced by Iranian-Americans.
- Foreign policy: Discuss how racial identity influences Iran's international relations.
- Solutions: Proposes diplomatic, domestic, and diaspora-based solutions to current tensions.
The Iranian Myth of "Whiteness": Historical Roots, Contemporary Perspectives, and International Implications:
1. Historical Context and Origins of the "White" Identity Myth.
1.1 The Aryan Myth and European Orientalism.
The term "Iranian" refers to the citizens or people of Iran, representing a nationality rather than a single race or ethnicity. Iran is a diverse country with multiple ethnic groups, including Persians, Azeris, Lurs, and others, all of whom are Iranian but not necessarily of the same ethnic or linguistic background. The Iranian people are classified under the Indo-Iranian language group, which is a major branch of the Indo-European language family. This broad category includes many languages, such as Persian, Balochi, and others spoken mainly in Iran and surrounding areas. Persian, the most well-known Iranian language, is a key part of this larger Indo-Iranian branch.
HISTORY
The historical construction of Iranian "whiteness' originates from 19th-century European Orientalism and racial science that ranked populations based on invented racial hierarchies. European scholars and philologists, especially Max Müller, popularized the term "Aryan" to describe Indo-European language speakers, including Europeans and Persians. This classification was later adopted by Iranian nationalist intellectuals during the late Qajar and Pahlavi eras (1925-1979), who aimed to create a modern national identity separate from both the Arab Islamic world and the Ottoman Empire. The Pahlavi monarchy, especially Reza Shah (1925-1941), actively promoted this ‘Aryan narrative’ as a state-led ideology to boost Iran's international prestige and justify internal modernization efforts. This involved highlighting pre-Islamic Persian heritage while minimizing the country's Islamic and multi-ethnic aspects. 1.2 Legal Classification in the United States.
CLASSIFICATION
The official classification of Iranians as ‘white’ in the United States has a specific legal history that still influences Iranian-American identity today. In the early 20th century, Iranians successfully petitioned U.S. courts for naturalization rights under racial eligibility rules that limited citizenship to "free white persons." In a key 1909 case, ‘In re Halladjian,’ a federal court labeled Iranians as Caucasian and therefore white, citing the Aryan myth and racial theories of that era. This legal label was confirmed in later cases and eventually included in U.S. census categories that classify people of Middle Eastern and North African (MENA) descent as white. This classification has created what sociologist Neda Maghbouleh calls a "racial paradox’—while officially recognized as white by the federal government, many Iranian-Americans experience everyday racialization that aligns more with communities of color, especially during times of increased geopolitical tension.
2. Contemporary Perspectives and Conditions.
2.1. Identity Negotiation in the Diaspora.
The Iranian diaspora, particularly in North America, continues to navigate complex racial landscapes that challenge notions of whiteness:
- Generational Divides: First-generation Iranian immigrants often hold on to a strong attachment to the Aryan identity narrative, seeing it as a sign of cultural superiority and a way to assimilate into white American society. In contrast, second-generation Iranian-Americans frequently challenge this narrative through their personal experiences with racialization and discrimination. Maghbouleh's research shows that these youth often participate in “self-directed research" about their roots and form solidarity networks with other racialized communities, including Latino, Arab, and South Asian peers.
- Situational Whiteness: Iranian-Americans experience what sociologists call "differential racialization" - their perceived racial identity shifts depending on the context. In official documents and settings where social mobility is emphasized, they may be seen as white, but in security checks (airports, border crossings) and during geopolitical tensions, they are distinctly racialized as Middle Eastern "others." This phenomenon is exemplified by the 2017 Muslim Ban, which targeted Iranians among other mostly Muslim countries, even though they are officially classified as white.
TENSIONS
Internalized Racism and Colorism: The Aryan myth has promoted internalized racism within Iranian communities, leading to anti-Arab and anti-Black prejudice and favoritism toward lighter skin tones. This has caused tension between official state classifications and the personal experiences of many Iranian-Americans who encounter discrimination and racial profiling.
2.2. Domestic Politics and International Relations.
Iran's foreign policy calculus is shaped by multiple intersecting factors that extend beyond but are influenced by notions of identity:
Table: Key Factors Shaping Iran's Foreign Policy
| --Factor-- | --Description-- | --Impact on Foreign Policy-- |
| --Economic Pressures-- | Severe economic challenges due to sanctions | Drives pragmatic engagement for economic relief |
| --Regional Rivalries-- | Competition with Saudi Arabia and Israel | Fuels proxy conflicts and nuclear ambitions |
| --Great Power Relations-- | Tensions with U.S.; growing ties with Russia/China | "Strategic eastward tilt" for sanctions evasion |
| --Domestic Politics-- | Power struggle between reformists and hardliners | Creates policy inconsistency and ideological posturing |
DIPLOMACY
- Strategic Pragmatism: Despite its revolutionary ideology, Iran's foreign policy shows significant pragmatic adaptation. The current leadership seems focused on economic diplomacy as a way to ease regional tensions, engage directly with business interests, and prioritize future cooperation over past hostilities. This includes seeking sanctions relief through careful negotiation while strengthening ties with Russia and China via organizations like BRICS and the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO).
POLICY
- Militarization of Foreign Policy: Under President Ebrahim Raisi (2021-2024), Iran experienced a significant shift toward centralizing foreign policy decisions within security agencies, especially the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) and the Supreme National Security Council (SNSC), sidelining the traditional Foreign Ministry. This shift has led to a more confrontational stance toward the West and a stronger focus on asymmetric warfare capabilities through proxy networks.
DYNAMICS
- Regional Dynamics: Iran's relations with Arab neighbors, especially Saudi Arabia, show a complex mix of ideological rivalry and practical cooperation. The 2023 China-brokered thaw with Saudi Arabia marks a strategic decrease in tension, although deep-rooted structural conflicts remain. Likewise, Iran's hostility toward Israel remains a core part of its regional strategy, driven by both ideological opposition and geopolitical competition for influence.
3. Implications and Possible Solutions.
3.1. Addressing Identity Complexities.
MENA
- Reforming Racial Classification: The proposed addition of a Middle Eastern and North African (MENA) category on U.S. census forms would address the statistical invisibility of Iranian-Americans and other MENA groups. Census Bureau research shows that when given this option, most MENA individuals choose it over "white." This change would improve data accuracy for tracking discrimination and directing resources to community needs.
EFFECTS
- Educational Initiatives: Within Iranian diaspora communities, there is a growing need for honest conversations about the origins and effects of the ‘Aryan myth’ and its links to ‘anti-Blackness’ and ‘anti-Arab racism’. This includes exploring how internalized racism influences community dynamics and solidarity with other marginalized groups.
ALLIANCES
- Solidarity Building: Iranian-Americans, especially youth, are increasingly forming alliances with other racialized groups. This grassroots effort challenges the isolation caused by the myth of whiteness and promotes stronger collective advocacy against Islamophobia, xenophobia, and racial profiling.
3.2 Diplomatic and Geopolitical Approaches.
- Nuclear diplomacy: Restarting the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) through good-faith negotiations remains essential for reducing tensions. This involves establishing verifiable limits on Iran's nuclear program in exchange for comprehensive sanctions relief, which could provide economic benefits and support pragmatic factions within Iran.
- Regional Dialogue Mechanisms: Creating inclusive regional security frameworks that involve Iran instead of isolating it could help address mutual security issues through diplomacy rather than proxy conflicts. The talks mediated by Oman between Iran and the U.S. serve as a potential model for this approach.
- People-to-People Exchanges: Increasing educational and cultural exchanges can help humanize Iranians to Americans and vice versa, countering decades of dehumanizing propaganda from both sides. These exchanges are especially important for breaking down the entrenched stereotypes that foster hostility.
Table: Solutions to Mitigate Tensions and Identity Conflicts.
| --Approach-- | --Specific Measures-- | --Expected Outcomes-- |
| --Domestic Reforms in Iran-- | Economic liberalization, political pluralism, human rights protections | Reduced external pressure, improved living standards, decreased migration pressure |
| --International Engagement-- | Nuclear diplomacy, sanctions relief, regional security dialogue | Reduced tensions, economic integration, stability |
| --Diaspora Initiatives-- | Inter-community solidarity, truth-telling about Aryan myth, advocacy | Stronger coalitions, reduced internalized racism, better policy representation |
| --Educational & Cultural-- | Academic exchanges, curriculum reforms, cultural diplomacy | Increased mutual understanding, reduced stereotypes |
4. Conclusion: Toward a Post-Whiteness Framework.
The Iranian myth of whiteness represents a complex historical construct with lasting effects on both the diaspora and Iran's international relations. Originally adopted as a strategy for modernization and prestige, the Aryan narrative has created problematic divisions within Iranian society and between Iran and its neighbors, while also failing to protect Iranian-Americans from racialization and discrimination.
Moving forward, addressing these challenges requires both internal reflection on the legacy of this racial myth and external diplomatic efforts that recognize Iran's legitimate security interests while promoting adherence to international norms.
For the diaspora, this means embracing a more inclusive identity that recognizes Iran's multi-ethnic landscape and fosters solidarity with other marginalized communities. For Iran's international relations, progress will depend on a pragmatic balance between necessary economic engagement with the West and strategic partnerships in the East, while gradually moving away from ideological posturing that has isolated the country.
Ultimately, overcoming the limitations of the whiteness myth—both within Iran and among its global diaspora—offers the potential for more genuine belonging and more constructive international relationships based on mutual respect rather than colonial-era racial hierarchies.
